Replacing an Older SEW-Eurodrive Gearbox Without Redesigning the Machine

Replacing an older SEW-EURODRIVE gearbox does not automatically require redesigning the machine around it.

In many industrial applications, the better objective is the opposite:

Preserve as much of the existing machine interface as possible while selecting a technically correct, supportable replacement gearbox.

That means maintaining the critical characteristics of the existing drive—including ratio, torque, output connection, motor interface, shaft location, mounting arrangement, and operating configuration—while determining where limited adaptation may be acceptable.

The challenge is that an older SEW-EURODRIVE model may have been installed decades ago.

Since then:

  • product families may have changed,

  • motor standards may have evolved,

  • housing designs may have been revised,

  • accessories may be different,

  • dimensional relationships may have changed and

  • the original exact configuration may no longer be available.

A current SEW-EURODRIVE product or another technically suitable equivalent may still be an excellent replacement.

But the interchange should be engineered around the machine, not merely the old model number.

The Goal: Replace the Gearbox, Not Redesign the Machine

When an aging gearbox fails, maintenance usually wants to preserve:

  • machine base,

  • driven shaft,

  • motor when practical,

  • coupling or driven connection,

  • guards,

  • structural steel,

  • surrounding equipment and

  • production process.

Every additional modification increases:

  • engineering time,

  • fabrication,

  • installation labor,

  • alignment work,

  • commissioning time and

  • downtime risk.

The ideal replacement therefore satisfies the application while minimizing machine changes.

Start With the Existing SEW-EURODRIVE Nameplate

Before looking for a replacement, document the existing gearbox completely.

Record:

  • manufacturer,

  • complete type/model designation,

  • serial number,

  • ratio,

  • motor information,

  • mounting information,

  • output configuration and

  • any additional codes shown on the nameplate.

Take several clear photographs.

Do not rely solely on a model description stored in the plant ERP.

Why the Complete Type Designation Matters

SEW-EURODRIVE gearboxes and gearmotors can incorporate configuration information involving:

  • gearbox family,

  • size,

  • ratio,

  • shaft arrangement,

  • mounting,

  • motor interface and

  • options.

An incomplete designation can omit information that matters to replacement selection.

What If the Nameplate Cannot Be Read?

Do not assume the gearbox cannot be identified.

Use:

  • remaining characters,

  • housing shape,

  • shaft arrangement,

  • motor nameplate,

  • ratio,

  • output speed,

  • mounting dimensions,

  • machine drawings,

  • historical purchase orders and

  • photographs.

See How to Source a Gearbox When the Nameplate Is Unreadable.

Photograph the Gearbox Before Removing It

Capture the installation from multiple angles.

Include:

  • complete gearbox,

  • motor,

  • input,

  • output,

  • mounting feet,

  • flange,

  • torque arm,

  • coupling,

  • driven shaft,

  • guards,

  • lubrication points,

  • breather,

  • accessories and

  • surrounding clearance.

The installed configuration often reveals information that cannot be reconstructed easily after the reducer is removed.

1. Verify the Application

Identify what the gearbox drives.

Examples include:

  • conveyor,

  • mixer,

  • agitator,

  • screw conveyor,

  • bucket elevator,

  • packaging machine,

  • process equipment,

  • material-handling system or

  • production machinery.

Record:

  • operating hours,

  • starts/stops,

  • reversing,

  • shock loading,

  • ambient conditions and

  • production criticality.

The replacement must satisfy the application, not simply resemble the old gearbox.

2. Verify Motor Power

Record the existing motor:

  • horsepower or kW,

  • RPM,

  • voltage,

  • frequency,

  • frame and

  • mounting configuration.

If a VFD is used, document the normal operating speed range.

3. Verify the Gear Ratio

Record the exact ratio when available.

The basic relationship is:

Output RPM = Input RPM ÷ Gear Ratio

If the input speed is:

1,750 RPM

and the ratio is:

25:1

the approximate output speed is:

70 RPM.

See Why Matching the Gear Ratio Isn't Enough When Replacing a Gearbox.

Ratio Is Only the Beginning

Two gearboxes can have the same ratio while differing substantially in:

  • torque capacity,

  • shaft diameter,

  • mounting,

  • motor adapter,

  • thermal capacity,

  • output bearing capacity and

  • overall dimensions.

Never approve a replacement based on ratio alone.

4. Verify Required Output Torque

A useful reference calculation is:

Torque (lb-ft) = HP × 5,252 ÷ RPM

For example:

30 HP at 70 RPM

produces approximately:

2,251 lb-ft

of torque.

The final selection should account for the manufacturer's rating method and the actual application duty.

5. Verify Mechanical Capacity

The proposed replacement must be adequately rated for:

  • continuous torque,

  • peak loads,

  • starts,

  • shock,

  • reversing,

  • overhung loads and

  • thrust loads where applicable.

Do not assume that matching motor horsepower establishes adequate gearbox capacity.

6. Verify Thermal Capacity

Thermal requirements become especially important for:

  • continuous-duty equipment,

  • high ambient temperatures,

  • high ratios,

  • enclosed areas and

  • demanding loads.

If the existing gearbox uses additional cooling, document it.

7. Identify the Output Arrangement

Determine whether the existing SEW-EURODRIVE gearbox has:

  • solid output shaft,

  • hollow shaft,

  • flange output or

  • another configuration.

This is one of the first mechanical interfaces that should be preserved if the objective is minimal machine modification.

See Hollow-Shaft vs. Solid-Shaft Gearbox Replacement.

8. Measure the Output Shaft

For a solid shaft, measure:

  • diameter,

  • shaft extension,

  • keyway,

  • shoulder,

  • engagement length and

  • shaft location.

If the existing coupling, sprocket, or sheave will be reused, these dimensions become especially important.

9. Measure the Hollow Bore

For hollow-shaft applications, document:

  • bore diameter,

  • keyway,

  • engagement length,

  • driven shaft diameter,

  • axial position and

  • locking arrangement.

See Keyed Hollow Bore vs. Shrink Disc vs. Taper Bushing: Which Connection Do You Need?.

Don't Change the Driven Shaft Unless You Have To

If a replacement requires machining or replacing the machine's driven shaft, the project has moved beyond a simple gearbox interchange.

That may still be justified.

But first investigate whether another gearbox configuration can preserve the existing shaft.

10. Identify the Input Arrangement

Determine whether the existing drive is:

  • integral gearmotor,

  • direct motor-mounted,

  • adapter-mounted,

  • separate-coupled or

  • belt driven.

The input arrangement can significantly affect how easily the replacement can be installed.

11. Decide Whether to Reuse the Existing Motor

This should be an explicit decision.

Reuse Existing Motor

Verify:

  • motor frame,

  • shaft,

  • pilot,

  • bolt pattern,

  • adapter and

  • overall length.

Replace Motor With Gearbox

A complete gearmotor replacement may sometimes simplify the project and improve future standardization.

Compare both approaches.

12. Verify NEMA vs. IEC Interface

An older installation may involve a motor interface that differs from the plant's current preferred standard.

See NEMA vs. IEC Motor Adapters on Industrial Gearboxes.

If the existing motor must remain, state that requirement clearly in the RFQ.

13. Measure the Mounting Footprint

For foot-mounted units, record:

  • front-to-back bolt spacing,

  • side-to-side bolt spacing,

  • mounting-hole diameter,

  • foot dimensions and

  • base dimensions.

Measure mounting holes center-to-center.

See How to Measure a Gearbox for Replacement.

14. Measure Center Height

Center height is:

Mounting Surface → Shaft Centerline

This dimension can determine whether the new gearbox aligns with the existing:

  • driven shaft,

  • coupling,

  • sprocket,

  • motor or

  • machine.

If center height changes, modifications may be required.

15. Measure Horizontal Shaft Position

Center height alone does not define shaft location.

Measure the shaft centerline relative to:

  • mounting holes,

  • base edge or

  • another fixed machine reference.

A replacement with the correct vertical centerline can still place the shaft too far forward or backward.

16. Check the Complete Envelope

Measure and photograph:

  • overall length,

  • width,

  • height,

  • motor projection,

  • shaft projection and

  • accessory clearance.

Then check surrounding:

  • guards,

  • structural members,

  • electrical equipment,

  • piping,

  • walkways and

  • adjacent machinery.

See Gearbox Replacement Dimensions: The Measurements That Determine Whether a Reducer Will Fit.

17. Verify Flange Dimensions

For flange-mounted units, compare:

  • flange diameter,

  • pilot,

  • bolt circle,

  • bolt-hole count,

  • hole diameter and

  • shaft location.

If these dimensions differ, a custom interface may be required.

18. Document the Physical Mounting Position

Do not rely only on the existing mounting-position code.

Document the actual orientation of:

  • input shaft,

  • output shaft,

  • gearbox housing and

  • motor.

See Understanding Gearbox Mounting Position Codes When Changing Manufacturers.

Mounting position can affect:

  • lubricant quantity,

  • oil level,

  • fill point,

  • drain,

  • breather,

  • bearing lubrication and

  • cooling.

19. Verify Rotation

Document output rotation and viewing direction.

For example:

Clockwise when viewed from the output-shaft end.

Do not simply write:

CW

without defining the viewpoint.

20. Verify Backstop Requirements

If the existing gearbox has a backstop, determine:

  • why it is installed,

  • required direction and

  • whether the replacement needs one.

This can be critical for:

  • inclined conveyors,

  • elevators and

  • gravity-loaded applications.

21. Verify Overhung Load

If the output shaft carries a:

  • sprocket,

  • sheave or

  • external gear,

verify the replacement's allowable load for the actual component position.

The distance from the gearbox bearing to the applied load matters.

22. Verify Thrust Load

Some applications create axial force.

If significant thrust exists, include it in the replacement review.

23. Verify Lubrication Requirements

Do not assume the replacement uses the same lubricant as the old SEW-EURODRIVE gearbox.

Document the existing configuration, but follow the current manufacturer's requirements for:

  • lubricant,

  • viscosity,

  • quantity,

  • fill,

  • drain and

  • breather.

24. Verify Cooling

Document any:

  • shaft fan,

  • electric fan,

  • cooling coil,

  • pump,

  • heat exchanger or

  • external lubrication system.

Compare thermal requirements rather than automatically transferring old accessories to the new gearbox.

25. Document Sensors and Accessories

Record:

  • temperature sensors,

  • vibration sensors,

  • oil-level switches,

  • heaters,

  • torque arms,

  • breathers,

  • sight glasses and

  • other options.

Make sure the supplier's quote clearly states what is included.

Step 26: Determine Whether a Current SEW-EURODRIVE Replacement Exists

Once the existing gearbox is documented, investigate the current product solution.

The current replacement might be:

Direct Replacement

Critical dimensions and interfaces remain compatible.

Near Drop-In

Minor adaptation is necessary.

Functional Replacement

Performance is suitable, but substantial dimensional differences exist.

Engineered Retrofit

The new gearbox requires planned modifications.

Do not use the term drop-in until the dimensions have been verified.

See What Does “Drop-In Gearbox Replacement” Actually Mean?.

A Current SEW-EURODRIVE Unit May Still Differ From the Old One

Product designs evolve.

Even when remaining with the same manufacturer, verify:

  • footprint,

  • center height,

  • shaft,

  • motor interface,

  • envelope,

  • accessories and

  • mounting position.

Same manufacturer does not guarantee identical dimensions across generations.

Step 27: Obtain the Dimensional Drawing

This is one of the most important steps.

Request the drawing for the exact proposed configuration.

Then compare it against:

  • original gearbox drawing,

  • field measurements and

  • machine dimensions.

Do not compare catalog photographs.

Compare dimensions.

Create a Dimensional Interchange Table

For example:

DimensionExisting SEWProposed ReplacementDifferenceRatio_________Center height_________Bolt spacing A_________Bolt spacing B_________Output shaft/bore_________Shaft extension_________Flange/pilot_________Overall length_________Overall width_________Overall height_________

This immediately identifies where redesign may be necessary.

Step 28: Separate “Must Match” From “Can Adapt”

This is one of the best ways to avoid unnecessary machine redesign.

Create two categories.

Must Match

Examples may include:

  • output speed,

  • required torque,

  • driven shaft,

  • rotation,

  • critical shaft location,

  • machine envelope.

Can Adapt

Depending on the application:

  • mounting holes,

  • coupling hub,

  • motor,

  • adapter plate,

  • fasteners,

  • guard.

This prevents the search from becoming unnecessarily restrictive.

Step 29: Use an Adapter Plate When Appropriate

Suppose the replacement provides:

  • correct performance,

  • correct output shaft,

  • acceptable shaft location

but has a different foot pattern.

An engineered adapter plate may preserve the existing machine base.

See When a Gearbox Interchange Requires an Adapter Plate—and When It Doesn't.

Adapter Plates Can Also Correct Modest Height Differences

Suppose:

Old gearbox center height = 10.00 inches

New gearbox center height = 9.50 inches

A properly engineered:

0.50-inch riser/adapter

may restore the shaft centerline.

But verify:

  • structural loading,

  • fasteners,

  • plate stiffness,

  • flatness,

  • alignment and

  • torque reaction.

Don't Use an Adapter to Rescue the Wrong Gearbox

An adapter plate cannot correct:

  • insufficient torque,

  • wrong ratio,

  • incompatible output connection,

  • inadequate thermal rating or

  • unsuitable bearing capacity.

The gearbox must be technically correct first.

Step 30: Change the Coupling Before Changing the Machine

For a separate-coupled drive, a shaft-diameter difference may sometimes be solved with a different coupling hub.

That is often far easier than:

  • modifying gearbox shafts,

  • machining the machine shaft or

  • relocating major equipment.

Evaluate the simplest controlled interface change first.

Step 31: Consider Replacing the Motor

For an older gearmotor, trying to preserve an obsolete motor interface can sometimes create more complexity than replacing the motor.

Compare:

Option A

New gearbox + custom interface to old motor

against:

Option B

Current gearbox + current motor package

The complete gearmotor may:

  • simplify engineering,

  • improve availability,

  • reduce future obsolescence and

  • improve plant standardization.

Step 32: Consider an Equivalent Manufacturer

The first choice does not necessarily have to remain SEW-EURODRIVE.

If another manufacturer offers:

  • better dimensional compatibility,

  • faster availability,

  • better plant standardization or

  • lower total installed cost,

it may deserve evaluation.

See OEM vs Equivalent Gearbox: What Procurement Teams Need to Know.

Brand Change Does Not Automatically Mean Machine Redesign

A properly selected gearbox from another manufacturer may fit an existing installation with:

  • no modification,

  • minor coupling changes or

  • a simple adapter.

See Can You Replace One Gearbox Brand With Another?.

The machine interface determines the difficulty—not the logo on the housing.

Step 33: Classify the Interchange

After reviewing the candidate, classify it.

Level 1 — True Drop-In

No meaningful machine modifications.

Level 2 — Near Drop-In

Requires limited adaptation such as:

  • coupling hub,

  • bushing,

  • shims or

  • adapter plate.

Level 3 — Engineered Retrofit

Requires:

  • base modification,

  • motor relocation,

  • shaft modification,

  • guard redesign or

  • significant fabrication.

See What Makes Two Industrial Gearboxes Truly Interchangeable?.

The Best Replacement May Be a Near Drop-In

Do not reject a technically strong replacement merely because four mounting holes differ.

If a simple adapter allows the plant to gain:

  • shorter lead time,

  • better support,

  • standardized spares and

  • improved future availability,

the near drop-in may be better than waiting months for an exact dimensional solution.

Step 34: Compare Total Installed Cost

Calculate:

Total Installed Cost = Gearbox + Motor + Freight + Engineering + Adapter + Coupling + Fabrication + Labor + Alignment + Commissioning

This is more useful than comparing gearbox prices alone.

See The True Cost of a Cheap Gearbox: Purchase Price vs Downtime Risk.

Example

Option A — Current OEM Configuration

Gearbox/gearmotor: $18,000
Modification: $1,000
Lead time: 14 weeks

Total installed cost before downtime:

$19,000

Option B — Approved Equivalent

Gearbox/gearmotor: $16,000
Adapter/coupling: $4,000
Lead time: 2 weeks

Total:

$20,000

Option A appears $1,000 less expensive.

But if production is down, 12 additional weeks of waiting may dwarf that difference.

Step 35: Compare Production Recovery Time

Calculate:

Production Recovery Time = Availability + Shipping + Fabrication + Installation + Alignment + Commissioning

See Gearbox Lead Times Explained: Stocked vs. Assembled vs. Modified vs. Custom Units.

The fastest gearbox to ship is not always the fastest solution to install.

Step 36: Engineer the Retrofit Before the Shutdown

If the replacement requires:

  • adapter,

  • coupling,

  • motor,

  • torque arm,

  • guard or

  • other modification,

complete the engineering before removing the existing gearbox whenever possible.

For a planned replacement:

  1. Measure.

  2. Select gearbox.

  3. Obtain drawing.

  4. Design modifications.

  5. Fabricate parts.

  6. Receive gearbox.

  7. Inspect everything.

  8. Begin shutdown.

That sequence can dramatically reduce installation risk.

Step 37: Build an Installation Kit

For important machines, stage:

  • gearbox,

  • motor if required,

  • adapter plate,

  • coupling,

  • bushings,

  • fasteners,

  • shims,

  • lubricant,

  • seals and

  • drawings.

A complete kit is far more valuable than a gearbox sitting alone in the storeroom.

Step 38: Require Supplier Deviations to Be Documented

When requesting an interchange, ask the supplier to identify differences from the existing gearbox.

For example:

Existing → Replacement

  • Ratio: Match

  • Output shaft: Match

  • Center height: Match

  • Bolt pattern: Different

  • Motor: New motor required

  • Adapter: Required

  • Backstop: Included

This makes the purchasing decision clearer.

Step 39: Send a Complete RFQ

Provide:

  • complete SEW-EURODRIVE model/type,

  • serial number,

  • nameplate photograph,

  • installation photographs,

  • application,

  • motor data,

  • ratio,

  • input/output speed,

  • shaft/bore dimensions,

  • mounting dimensions,

  • mounting position,

  • rotation,

  • accessories,

  • drawing if available and

  • required delivery date.

See Industrial Gearbox Procurement Checklist: What to Send With an RFQ.

Step 40: Obtain Approval Drawings Before Ordering

For a critical interchange, the sequence should be:

Quote → Drawing Review → Technical Approval → Purchase Order

not:

Purchase Order → Gearbox Arrives → Discover Differences

Put the Drawing Revision on the Purchase Order

The PO should identify:

  • manufacturer,

  • complete configuration,

  • ratio,

  • motor,

  • accessories,

  • quote revision and

  • approved drawing revision.

See What Information Should Be on a Gearbox Purchase Order?.

Inspect the Gearbox Before the Planned Shutdown

When the replacement arrives, verify:

  • model,

  • ratio,

  • motor,

  • output shaft/bore,

  • mounting,

  • accessories,

  • backstop and

  • visible condition.

Measure critical dimensions if necessary.

Do not discover an order discrepancy after production has already stopped.

Step 41: Align and Commission Properly

A mechanically compatible gearbox can still fail prematurely if installation is poor.

Follow appropriate procedures for:

  • mounting,

  • soft-foot correction,

  • shaft alignment,

  • coupling alignment,

  • lubrication,

  • fastener torque and

  • commissioning.

Follow the manufacturer's current installation instructions for the replacement gearbox.

Step 42: Update the Asset Register

After successful installation, record:

Original SEW-EURODRIVE Unit → Approved Replacement

Include:

  • new manufacturer,

  • model/type,

  • serial,

  • ratio,

  • motor,

  • adapter,

  • coupling,

  • lubricant,

  • installation date,

  • drawing and

  • supplier.

See How to Create a Gearbox Asset Register Before Your Equipment Fails.

Preserve the Legacy Cross-Reference

Do not erase the old SEW-EURODRIVE information.

Historical:

  • machine drawings,

  • work orders,

  • manuals,

  • spare lists and

  • purchase records

may continue referring to the original gearbox.

Maintain a permanent cross-reference.

Use the First Replacement to Standardize the Others

If the plant has multiple identical older SEW-EURODRIVE units, a successful interchange can become the standard replacement package.

Document:

  • replacement gearbox,

  • motor,

  • adapter,

  • coupling,

  • hardware,

  • lubricant and

  • installation procedure.

Now future replacements require much less engineering.

Consider Stocking the Engineered Replacement

If several critical machines use the old gearbox, consider stocking the approved replacement package.

See How to Build a Critical Gearbox Spare Strategy for Your Plant.

One properly configured spare may protect multiple assets.

Older SEW-EURODRIVE Gearbox Replacement Checklist

Before approving the replacement:

Identification

  • Complete model/type

  • Serial number

  • Ratio

  • Nameplate photographed

  • Installation photographed

  • Existing drawing located

Application

  • Driven equipment

  • Motor HP/kW

  • Input RPM

  • Output RPM

  • Duty

  • Shock/reversing

  • Environment

Output

  • Solid/hollow shaft

  • Shaft/bore measured

  • Keyway documented

  • Connection method identified

  • Overhung load considered

  • Thrust load considered

Input

  • Motor interface documented

  • Motor frame documented

  • Existing motor reuse decision made

  • Coupling documented

Installation

  • Bolt pattern

  • Center height

  • Horizontal shaft location

  • Flange

  • Overall envelope

  • Clearance

  • Guarding

Configuration

  • Mounting position

  • Rotation

  • Backstop

  • Lubrication

  • Cooling

  • Sensors/accessories

Replacement

  • Technical rating verified

  • Exact drawing reviewed

  • Differences documented

  • Adapter engineered

  • Coupling selected

  • Motor selected

  • Installation kit prepared

  • Lead time confirmed

  • Total installed cost evaluated

What Must Match—and What Can Be Changed?

The most efficient replacement projects distinguish between the two.

Usually Must Match

Depending on the application:

  • required output speed,

  • torque/capacity,

  • driven connection,

  • critical shaft position,

  • rotation and

  • application requirements.

Often Can Be Adapted

Depending on engineering:

  • bolt pattern,

  • motor,

  • coupling,

  • adapter,

  • base interface,

  • fasteners and

  • guard.

That distinction is how plants avoid unnecessary machine redesign.

Replacing an Older SEW-EURODRIVE Gearbox: The Bottom Line

An aging SEW-EURODRIVE gearbox should not be replaced by asking only:

“What is the new model number?”

A better process is:

Document → Measure → Define Must-Match Requirements → Select → Compare Drawings → Engineer Minimal Adaptation → Approve → Install

The best replacement preserves the machine interfaces that are expensive or difficult to change while allowing manageable differences where adaptation is economical.

In many cases, that means the plant does not need to redesign the machine.

It may need only:

  • a different coupling hub,

  • a properly engineered adapter plate,

  • a current motor,

  • minor mounting changes or

  • a carefully selected equivalent gearbox.

The important work happens before the purchase order.

Preserve the machine where it matters. Adapt the interfaces where it makes sense. Engineer the replacement before the old gearbox becomes an emergency.

Need Help Replacing an Older SEW-EURODRIVE Gearbox?

Industrial Gearbox Supply can help evaluate replacement options for aging, discontinued, or difficult-to-source SEW-EURODRIVE gearboxes and gearmotors.

Useful information includes:

  • complete model/type designation,

  • serial number,

  • nameplate photographs,

  • installation photographs,

  • motor nameplate,

  • application,

  • ratio,

  • input/output speed,

  • shaft or bore dimensions,

  • mounting dimensions,

  • mounting position and

  • required delivery timeframe.

A replacement review can then evaluate:

  • current OEM solutions,

  • equivalent manufacturers,

  • dimensional compatibility,

  • motor compatibility,

  • adapter requirements,

  • coupling modifications,

  • lead time and

  • total installed cost.

The objective is simple: replace the aging gearbox while changing as little of the machine as practical.

Sources

SEW-EURODRIVE
Official manufacturer resources for gearmotors, gear units, motors, industrial gear units, technical documentation, and product support.
https://www.sew-eurodrive.com/

SEW-EURODRIVE — Gear Units
Official product information covering SEW-EURODRIVE gearbox families and drive configurations.
https://www.sew-eurodrive.com/products/gear_units/gear_units.html

SEW-EURODRIVE — Industrial Gear Units
Official information covering industrial gear units, application configurations, and related drive technologies.
https://www.sew-eurodrive.com/products/gear_units/industrial_gear_units/industrial_gear_units.html

American Gear Manufacturers Association (AGMA)
Standards and technical resources covering industrial gearing, rating, application, and terminology.
https://www.agma.org/

NORD DRIVESYSTEMS — Industrial Gear Units
Manufacturer information useful when evaluating alternative industrial gearbox configurations.
https://www.nord.com/en/products/industrial-gear-units/industrial-gear-units.jsp

Sumitomo Drive Technologies
Industrial reducer and gearmotor resources useful when evaluating alternative replacement configurations.
https://us.sumitomodrive.com/en-us/products

Next
Next

Boston Gear Replacement: What Must Match Before Selecting an Equivalent